Purpose To make disciples for Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world Purpose To make disciples for Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world


Attract people to Christ
Build committed Christians
Commission disciples for ministry in our world


Inspired by God
Founded by Christ
Powered by the Holy Spirit


First United Methodist Church of Broken Arrow is a local congregation of the global United Methodist Church. This congregation was established on the corner of College and Main in downtown Broken Arrow in 1903.
We’ve been creating disciples for Christ for over 118 years.


We are committed to reaching out beyond the church walls to display the love of Christ through service, hospitality and meeting the needs of our local community and beyond.


Larry Varvel

Senior Pastor

Larry Varvel

Senior Pastor

Senior Pastor Larry Varvel was born in Bartlesville, Oklahoma in 1959. His family moved to Tulsa in 1971 and Larry graduated from Tulsa Memorial High School in 1978. Larry then attended the University of Oklahoma in Norman as a National Merit Scholar where he was awarded a Bachelor’s degree in Letters in 1981 and a Master’s degree in Philosophy in 1983. He then moved to Pasadena, California to attend Fuller Theological Seminary. Larry graduated from Fuller with a Master’s degree in Divinity in 1986 and was ordained as a United Methodist pastor that same year.

Prior to his coming to Broken Arrow in 2003, Larry served as the Associate Pastor at Wesley UMC in Oklahoma City (1986-1988), pastor of the First UMC of Atoka, OK (1988-1990), OK; pastor of Quail Springs UMC in Oklahoma City (1990-1997), and Senior Pastor of the First UMC of Ada, OK (1997-2003). While serving in Ada, Larry was awarded the Denman Award for Excellence in Evangelism by the United Methodist Foundation for Evangelism.

Larry and Jeanine have three children: Patty Deras and her husband, Andrew and their son, Leo; Lainie Schick, and her husband Taylor; and Andrew Varvel and his wife Elyssa. Larry and Jeanine enjoy traveling, movies, and spending time with family.

Larry Varvel

Senior Pastor

Graeme Collett

Associate Pastor

Graeme Collett joined staff at First United Methodist Broken Arrow, on January 1, 2014, as Director of Student Ministries before becoming the Associate Pastor. Graeme previously served three and a half years as Director of Student Ministries at Sand Springs United Methodist Church.

He recently graduated from seminary at Asbury Theological Seminary in Wilmore, Kentucky via their XL (extended learning program) in May 2021.

He graduated from Oklahoma State University with a Bachelor of Science in Psychology in 2010. During his time at OSU, Graeme founded and directed a non-profit mission organization that sent mission teams internationally to both Uganda, and Mexico.

He was born in Manitoba, Canada, raised in Nebraska.  He met his wife, Jetonne, while they were attending OSU. Graeme and Jetonne have been married for almost 11 years and they have two beautiful sons Micah and Levi. The Collett Family loves Oklahoma State Football, going to the splash pad, zoo, and spending time with friends and family.


Karen Lawless

Children’s Director

Jenny Brown

Associate Children’s Director

Shawna Gall

Pre-School Director

Andrew Varvel

Student Ministries Co-Director

Emily McKenzie

Student Ministries Co-Director

Laryn Moore

College Age Ministry Director

Ross Crawford

Modern Worship Leader

Mark Frie

Traditional Worship Leader

Cassie Chambers

Digital Communications

Kathy Glassco

Business Administrator

Tammy Lind

Finance Clerk

Rita Sorrels


Address: 112 E College Street, Broken Arrow, OK 74012  |  Phone: 918-258-1505